Mud-Bath Emporiums
02:55 PM February 05, 2008 4 comments »
If you can’t shake winter’s chill, get into hot water in Calistoga, that famous 19th-century spa town at the north end of Napa Valley. Sitting directly atop volcanic hot springs, Calistoga is chockablock full of hydrotherapy spas and mud-bath emporiums. (To learn what a mud bath is, watch the slideshow on the main Calistoga page, where you can also find tips on where to stay and eat.) I won’t lie to you: Some of the town’s spas are dirty, what with all that mud slinging. Stick to the following places for maximum cleanliness.
Weekend Hotel Deals - from KAYAK
The first-choice Indian Springs was founded in 1861, and it remains the town’s premier mud-bath emporium because it has the best real estate. Sitting atop a boiling hot springs, the resort has an unlimited supply of 230º water to feed the baths and giant swimming pool. Best of all, the spa uses 100% volcanic ash, mined from their own property. (Most spas use a combination of ash and peat, but nothing detoxifies as effectively as ash.) For the full treatment, follow your mud bath with an hour-long massage. Men and women are segregated, as at all mud-bath emporiums. Afterward, bite into an unlimited supply of juicy orange slices and slather on the spa’s own delicious cucumber body lotion. Perfect.
The second-choice Dr. Wilkinson’s opened in 1952, and uses a combination of two-thirds ash and one-third peat. The sensation is different; the mud is waterier and more buoyant. I prefer the feeling of heavy, dense mud bearing down on me, but if you tend to get claustrophobic, you might prefer the Doc to Indian Springs.
The new fancy-pants spa is Solage, an Auberge du Soleil property that opened this past summer. The mud baths here aren’t the traditional sort. Instead you choose the type of mud you want from their ‘mud bar,’ and paint it on yourself while swilling wine. Afterward, hit the circuit of hydrotherapy tubs. Men and women are segregated in the bathhouse, which means you can go nude. Solage is very un-Calistoga, geared toward the new-money LA set, not folksy old-school Californians. I’ve toured the property, though I haven’t yet had a chance to soak here. Overall I find the high style a bit aggressive for this sleepy town, but if you’re a skirt-and-sweater traveler, you might just love it. I’ll report back as soon as I’ve had a bath here. Meanwhile, if you’ve been to Solage, feel free to post a comment at the bottom of the page. I’m eager to get others’ feedback.
For traditional spa treatments, you have several clean-hands options. The top-choice Lavender Hill Spa has treatment rooms inside several small cottages built into a hillside. It’s ideal for couples’ fango-mud treatments (paint-on body masks) and couples’ massages (though the room where they do the couples’ massages gets a bit of road noise from Hwy 29 outside). The service—attentive and polite—is some of the best in town. Can’t plan ahead? Ask about the 20% discount on same-day treatment appointments.
Mount View Spa is one of the prettiest in town because it was designed by the folks at Joie de Vivre, who then (alas) lost the contract on the spa. Mount View is a good backup for classic treatments, aromatherapy baths, and lube jobs with Dr. Hauschka products. Nine treatment rooms mean more available appointments.
Happy Thanksgiving!



December 8th, 2007 at 2:21 pm
Oh no… now the secret is out.
Indian Springs is wonderful..
December 11th, 2007 at 6:59 pm
Aynne,
Alas, this is the curse of being a travel writer: publicizing your favorite places, then finding yourself unable to get a booking because you helped make it popular. But Indian Springs is just too good not to share. See you on the road.
Best,
John
April 3rd, 2008 at 12:58 pm
John,
Hello and how are you? BTW, your website is on my top ten list!
Okay, so my boyfriend and I spent an afternoon at Solage last week. I can honestly say that we won’t be coming back.
I realize this is a new resort but I didn’t expect it to look like construction was finished yesterday. If I’m going to drop $500 here for an afternoon (approx 2 hours) I want to feel like I’m in paradise. The landscaping and “bungalows” were plain and lacked any sort character.
We signed up for their mudslide package for two. First you get to choose one of four oils/scents to go into a small bucket of mud. You then go into a tiled room that’s heated and contains several shower heads. You slop the mud on yourself and sit for twenty minutes before someone knocks on the door indicating it’s time to rinse off.
Now on to step two. After rinsing off you walk to another room that’s sectioned off my tall curtains. In your section is a tub. Nothing fancy, just a tub filled with warm water. They call it thermal something something but it’s just a tub of water. You sit in your tub for ten minutes and then there’s a knock on the door indicating it’s time to get out.
Last, but not least, you’re led into another semi-private room. This room contains a big vibrating chair. You sit in the chair and it vibrates with music. My attendant placed headphones on my ears, wrapped me in blankets, reclined my chair and said she’d be back in twenty minutes. Those were the longest twenty minutes ever! I felt bored, anxious, and warm sitting in this chair. It wasn’t one of those fun massaging chairs, it just vibrated to random/errie Native American music.
After the chair I had the option to change into a swimsuit and hang out in their heated mineral water pool. BUT this isn’t the pool you’d swim in if you were staying at the resort. It’s a segregated pool! Isn’t the whole point of coming to a RESORT for spa treatment to be able to rub elbows with high rollers!!!??? I expected to hang out by the pool for a couple of hours, read my book, order a cocktail. Didn’t happen. No one ever come over to offer us a drink. If and when we did see other forms of life, the place was deserted, we got a “oh you’re still here” smile. We swam around in the lonely pool for about 10 minutes and then left.
We wanted to spend a relaxing day in Calistoga and visit Indian Springs. Unfortunately Indian Springs was booked and that was the only day we could get off from work. We didn’t have to leave San Francisco to get what Solage had to offer. Ahh, and to think I could have spent a day at the Four Season’s Spa in SF and saved ourselves from driving in traffic and hiring a pet sitter. Maybe Solage is great for someone not coming from a big city?
Anyway, sorry for the long comment. Thanks for putting together such and amazing website. I always look forward to your emails.
Warm Regards,
Jessica
(San Francisco)
April 3rd, 2008 at 8:51 pm
Hi Jessica,
Thanks for the exhaustive critique! These are just the sorts of details that readers need to know when choosing a spa.
I’ve been withholding judgment about Solage while they get up and running. I agree, the place looks like a shaved dog: the landscaping definitely needs help. But I haven’t yet tried the spa, so I can’t comment. I shall pay close attention to the problems you address in your critique. (BTW, I l-o-v-e-d your thoughts about the vibrating chair. So funny!)
Thanks again. Looking forward to your next comment!
Best,
John